Monday, November 16, 2026

A Response to Paul Krugman's "Climates of Treason"

Paul Krugman, as usual, is largely spot on with his Substack video essay, "Climates of Treason."

However, as I get older, I defend much of the Cambridge Five's thinking and what they did in the 1930s and 1940s because they were acting much more in response to the British wealthy elite and hanging-on monarchs being pro-Fascist Italy and pro-Nazi Germany. The Cambridge Five understood much of what Stalin did in terms of betraying most of the Bolshevik (Leninist) ideals, which one finds buried deep in their particular conversations with colleagues, or in letters or journals (one also sees this with biologist JBS Haldane, and historians EP Thompson and Eric Hobsbawm). However, these then-younger British diplomats and government officials knew King Edward and many British elites were continually playing footsie and favorites with the Fascist and Nazi governments. This was a major motivator in why they concluded they should act to protect the Revolution in the Soviet Union from a never formalized, but definitely real Fascist International. Most of them were particularly appalled by the Fascist aggression in Spain during the mid to late 1930s, and acutely aware of German Nazi and Italian Fascist government military and political support for the Spanish Fascists, all at a critical time before the start of World War II in Europe on September 1, 1939. The Cambridge Five were also deeply intelligent men, who had a grasp of historical trends and one or more of the arts. They were initially enamored with socialist and communist ideals because they thought people in and beyond Britain ought to be kinder to each other. That remains the fundamental difference between Communists and Nazis, as there is no love for humanity as a whole in Nazism or for that matter Fascism. Naziism and Fascism in general are about a desire for hierarchies of control, and preferably male dominance over women. Krugman is one of those liberals who continually see Communism and Fascism/Nazism as essentially the same, which is why he jumped so readily to mention the Cambridge Five.

We can't say any of what we say about the Cambridge Five about Trump, the people around Trump, and the modern business magnates, in tech and oil industries, especially. The latter are largely men, with some women, who are uncurious about history, sociology, and anthropology, have no ear for music or poetry, and think they understand economics because of the ahistorical, biologically ignorant neoclassical economics they learned in business schools, which essentially told them their personal greed is "good" for society. Plus, and this is really important both in the 1930s Fascism/Naziism and now, they really believe themselves superior and want to lord it over others. So why then do these modern fascistic US elites not like Stalin? Well, if they did, that would obligate them to help build up their nation while helping others who they are not "liquidating." For it remains a fact that Stalin's regime lifted out of poverty tens of millions of Russians AND non-Russians in the Soviet Union (Stalin's late paranoia about Jewish people definitely notwithstanding). Most economists in US business schools will have to admit that the Soviet Union went from 1/100th of US GNP in 1920 to 1/10th in 1960, the same period of time the US massively grew its gross national product or output. And there was more gender and sexual equality in the Soviet Union in this period, which is deeply ironic at least to me. I also always say a person such as me was precisely one of the first ones who Stalin exiled, tortured, or killed as those with my point of view would have fallen into what was known as the Left Opposition to Stalin. Most ironic. It is why my hero is the Left Oppositionist, Victor Serge, who was internally exiled, and then would have been murdered but for French Communists such as Andre Gide publicly and privately demanding Stalin release Serge--which happened to be just before Stalin began his major purges against much of the Bolsheviks (It is sometimes said Stalin may have killed more Bolshevik activists than the Czar/White Army in the Soviet Civil War (1918-1921)--in a gallows humor sort of way). 

This is also why these men currently controlling the US economy and government don't like the Chinese post-bourgeois democracy under President Xi, where there is no choice in elections besides Communist Party members, but where lots of policy changes, local and national, continue to be debated and enacted, often with the support of the vast majority of the populace. Krugman definitely understands that, as he says in his essay. As Krugman would also agree, to the extent these men like North Korea's Kim, Kim reflects something they don't want to admit, which is they are fragile buffoons who need constant media reinforcement and personal loyalty. Krugman also sees the strongmen these Trump and business magnate people admire are Putin, Netanyahu, Bolsonaro, and Orban. Those are men who give the people very little economic benefits, but either lord it over them like Putin, Bolsonaro, and Orban, or, like Putin and Netanyahu, massively murder others outside their borders to gin up nationalism at home while they rob their fellow citizens blind.

I hope I am clear why Krugman is largely correct, but is ultimately too facile in comparing these modern elite men and women with the Cambridge Five. Krugman is certainly onto something in understanding what Trump and our economic overlords are currently about. What Krugman is less willing to interrogate is why Trump is more the RESULT of what Cold War and Reagan/Clinton's policies have wrought, and why capitalism is never really about "free" markets, but capitalists and various economic or political elites continually using government for their own ends. One may also then see what Krugman will really never understand, which is how the concepts of socialism and communism represent not so much a threat to people's day-to-day lives, but more of a recognition of what the late Robert Heilbronner called "worldly philosophers" have thought about for thousands of years, which is finding the right balance in society for people to live in dignity, have economic security, and enough liberty to complain to public officials when a pothole needs filling, build something new to help people, or otherwise leave people be in finding love and comfort, or pursuing art.:)